00:00
00:00
View Profile Shellac

24 Audio Reviews

18 w/ Responses

Beautifully played!

This certainly made a change to all the stuff I usually hear on NG!

I wasn't familiar with the song before this and your version sounds a quite different to the original. Once I was finished with your version I listened to the original and wasn't expecting it to be so upbeat! You're version is a lot more emotional and melancholic. Don't know if you were going for that but it's a testament to your technique if you can change the character of a song simply with the way you play it.

I think I can hear a really subtle string part going on in the background here. It's a little too low in the mix, the piano does a fair job of burying it! I'd also like to hear the piano spread in stereo a bit more, it's all down the middle so there's a lot of space to fill.

I don't normally like instrumentals but I enjoyed this one. Excellent playing, it was really nice to hear.

Jabicho responds:

Hi there! Thanks for listening! It's cool to know it had a change to give it my personal sign, thanks for saying that!
Yeah, I'm gonna get another cable so it could record in stereo, it'll be awesome to get one! Thanks for the review, suggestions and support!, take care!

Cool dirty electro!

Logic FTW!!!!

Pretty interesting track you've got here! There's lots and lots of detail, it's nice and busy but there's still a lot of space which is very hard to do. There's a good deal of attention paid to stereo imaging and the parts really compliment each other well.

You have cool melodies, good bass, good drum grooves that change around a fair bit. I like the Ridge Racer jazz chords that come in on 0:33 seconds. I also like the strings, they remind me of 'Push The Button' by the Chemical Brothers. I think you guys would enjoy One Watt Sun.

http://onewattsun.com/audio.html

You seem to have a similar ethos to them; mid tempo, intricate stereo imaging, lots of little details, a fair bit of dirt.... Give 'em a listen!

Some of the cymbals are a little bit cheesy but in general the sounds are really good. Mastering wise, maybe you need to bring out the bass a bit more. The kick and the snare particularly don't appear to have a lot of punch to them. I'm not sure exactly what it is but for some reason the overall sound is a little bit weedy.

I really like the track overall though. There's lots of stuff to pick out and it warranted repeated listens. I love the cheeky cowbell on 2:46! Good stuff.

Review Request Club.

SymbolCymbal responds:

Wow thank you for the awesome review.
You right i was thinking about redoing the sounds of the drums i really just got lazy on it. Zstriefel composed all the drum but i redid them with different drum sounds..have no idea why i did that.

but yeah im glad you liked the stereo imaging. i actually spent a good amount of time on the train to work trying to get the sound in the headphones to match the sound in my head.

there actually is a whole storyline for this song, i have been looking for a lyricist/MC to compose the lyrics to no avail.. im not a very poetic or lyrical person.. i just have ideas.. yeah so i wrote a storyline for the song...... AAAAAANNNNDDDD here it is!

Beginning half intro :00 - :15
Builder is complaining about living in his mothers basement and mentioning his collection of music and audio equipment. As well and talking about how he has no friends.

End half of beginning intro :15 - :31
He has a eureka moment with the idea to build a robot from all the audio equipment he owns.

First Verse :31 - 1:20
He starts listing off equipment he has as well as preposterous notions as to what the robot will be made with. EX- Killing T-pain and putting his soul in a jar for the robots heart. Shoving a flux capacitor up the robots ass so the robot can travel through time. Chest is a subwoofer- head is a midi processor, legs are modified keytars, a therimin for a tail...etc.etc. At end of verse he says "And i named him Mr. Funkhousen"

Organ lead to bridge 1:21 - 1:45
He turns on the power to bring Mr. F to life, It doesnt work at first and he gets frustrated. power turns off at 1:35. his mother screams from upstairs about the noise at one point.

Organ bridge 1:45 - 1:52
Mr. F auto-tune groans and comes to life.

Organ Melody - 1:52 - 2:23
After coming to life mr.f sings about his capabilities and statuses. such as count bpm, rip a wicked keytar solo, flying, moonwalking and traveling through time, At one point he sings like barry white when he sings "And i can sound like Barry White for the ladies"... MR.F tells him to hop on to go to a party at a club in the year 2510~~or whatever rhymes with what is said.
At this point the builder is just a hype man agreeing and WOWing.

Hip Hop Club Bridge 2:23 - 2:55
Builder narrates that they arrive to a club floating thousands of feet up in the sky. They open the door and walk into the club in slow motion. Builder raps about Mr, F's ability to dance, blast music from his chest, How good he is with the ladies 'Shortay" Mr. F is singing along in the background and singing little things as builder raps.

1st half outro 2:55 - 3:11
Builder raps about how mr F grabbed a bottle of hennesy, chugs it and suggests they go hit an after party on new years eve 2999.

Outro 3:11 - END
Builder and Mr. F sing and rap about how this was the beginning of a great friendship between a man and a funky singing dancing robot. They go on about how they plan to keep hitting parties and travel through time together for the rest of eternity.

please let me know if you know anyone that can help out with this..

BTW_ i checked out the one watt sun link.. and you were right .. i INDEED liked it..one problem.. i cant seem to find out where i can get more of thier music.. i checked itunes and couldnt find em... i definitly digged their song aliens.

well anyway thank you for the sweet review.. it had showed me that ues ineed i need to get back on those cymbal hits and some of the drum sounds.

i give your a review a ten lolololol

peace love happiness and crunchy tunes lol
symbol:cymbol

Not bad.

This one's OK as a basic idea but you could do a lot of things to make it more interesting. At the moment it sounds like a backing track, you are definitely in need of a main melody or a vocal. The track is alright as it is now but it's not very inspiring.

The drums are distorting like mad. That needs to be fixed big time. It's pretty low in the mix so I guess you're driving the kick drum part into clipping with gain and then you've brought the level down in the mix rather than reducing the gain. There's a bit during the build after the 1:30 where the arpeggios come in again where as the other parts fade back in, you lose volume on the kick. I don't know if this is intentional but it sounds a little strange.

You have to change the drum groove up a little in places by programming in some breaks as it gets a little boring listening to the same rhythm the whole time. I would also consider changing your chord sequences around a bit. I do like the feel of the piece generally but it sounds unfinished at the moment and needs more work on the melodic parts. I do like the sweep on the arpeggio at the beginning but it's not enough to hold my interest throughout the whole piece.

Review Request Club

Catchy!

Nice song! I like the sentiment in the lyrics and I like your vocals. You have an individual sound, like a mix between Bon-Jovi and Bob Dylan.

Your instrumentation is cool but your mix is a bit on the trebly side, I'm not getting much on the bass and I reckon that's because you haven't used a kick drum that I can hear. There should definitely be a kick in there or it should be louder if you have one already. I kept expecting a drop and not getting it, which is cool for suspense but not if it never arrives. I feel cheated!

That hook just before the synth solo bit and at the end is really nice and I think you should lead that into a minor sounding section at the end. Repeat that melody a few times and build a progression around that as an outro or something.

I really enjoyed this song though you have a really good voice and your instrumentation is excellent. I look forward to hearing more!

Good first attempt!

This is pretty good, not bad for a first attempt. You have a melody which instantly gives you more than half. I don't think there's enough in the melody however. The part where the synth kicks in at 1:45 is a welcome change from the staccato line on the piano but I think it needs to be more complex.

I'm not a huge fan of the repeated sections either. There needs to be more variation in there. You've missed a massive opportunity to get some really fast, rhythmic gated pads on the second repeat. This track could really do with something like the pads in 'My Love' by Justin Timberlake.

I like your bass line to be honest. It reminds me of Kylie Minogue's recent stuff. Take that as a compliment or not but you can't fault the guys working on her production. You could try adding in the lower octave pulse on the beat to compliment the higher octave on the offbeat and fill out the low without changing the character... disco it up!

Your fade-out at the end is a little long but the loop is really good. This is a great first effort and I reckon there's better to come. Work on your melodies and variation. I wanted to give you 6.5 sooo 6/10 and 4/5.

Review Request Club.

Dj-GST responds:

Thanks man.

You got some good points, and to be honest, I'm glad you gave me a six.

I'll work on the repetitiveness, and I'll work on the pads a bit.

Very enjoyable!

Nicely done man, I really like it! I've listened to it a fair few times now and I'm still enjoying it. Your 8 bit sonata section sounds like something from a Genghis Tron break. If you're not afraid of heavy music, I'd give them a listen! They're a little bit mind blowing. And shouty...

I love your nice laid back drum beat and the noise elements mixed with the real cymbal sounds. If anything, I think there is a lack of real instrumentation. I'm not saying hire a string section or anything but it would be really nice to hear some string-like pads swoop in under the repeat of the theme for example. I think the lead line could be a little more expressive, adding in some vibrato on the long notes would make the part more interesting. Have a listen to some stuff made in Famitracker, I find it really easy to get expressive synth parts in that program. I use Famitracker in nearly all of my tracks somewhere along the line!

This piece has an excellent feel and you are brave for attempting a track of this length but I thoroughly enjoyed it. You're on my favourite artists!

Review Request Club.

Cornilious responds:

And I thought that no one from the RRC would respond =P

I agree with the instrumentation. Now that I've heard it so much, some variance in the repeats of the theme would be good.

I'm using FL and Studio One so I don't think I'll look into Famitracker (8-bit isn't my primary style anyway) since learning a new program isn't high on the agenda.

Thanks for the add! I'm hoping to produce more organic tracks like rock (like my previous tracks "Coming Home" and "Beautiful Sound"), synth-pop, and acoustic pieces once this semester of college is over.

Hopefully this summer I'll put some quality tracks up!

It would work better as an alarm!

It would irritate me so much that I'd want to get up and turn it off as soon as possible! Big, brash lead line with lotsa bass and lotsa drums. There's a clear melody, a few interesting drum fills and sweeps and some cool arpeggios... Very good as a ring tone.

I would like to hear it when you do make it a full song and I'll probably mark it higher when it has more dynamics and maybe a less annoying lead sound.

Review Request Club.

very cool intro

I'm not going to list all the elements I like here because you know what you've done. I'm only giving it 7 because it's not finished and I need somewhere to go if you were to submit it for review when you are done!

I don't like the glitchy snare sound at 1:36, that's a bit random and then it keeps repeating sporadically and gets annoying because it ruins the flow. I reckon you should go for a latin feel instead of the snare. Add in some big deep drums maybe like the ones in the back row here;

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QR0rOi t22sk

That's my only criticism really, I can't fault it other than that. I love your reverse sounds at the start, it builds really nicely and then sorta fades into nothing...

You know what you need for the next bit... A nice groove with hats on the off beat, a big dirty bassline, a nice expressive lead sound with plenty of gliss. and vibrato, a few harmonies.... Some strings maybe? Or you could throw a curve ball and turn it into a spooky sounding glitch track. It's coming along though I'd like to hear the full version.

Review Request Club.

mmmburgers responds:

Thanks for the review, as for the snare. If you listen to Hard Dance and Hard Trance will you encounter that type of snare roll alot. Haha. Only sticking to the roots of the genre.

Euphoric!

This track's pretty good. I reckon it's more techno oriented than house but it's pretty subjective! I would regard this as house;

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=73kozp 74V5k&feature=PlayList&p=3F19A16F3076 DF5F&playnext_from=PL&playnext=1&inde x=7

Lots of funk influence, a female vocal, slower disco tempo etc.

You have paid a lot of attention to the dynamics in your track and all the various builds keep the song sounding fresh. I like the way you gradually bring up the detail in the frequency spectrum of the piano and that little lead into the bassline is cool. It's good to hear the piano with a fair stereo image, so that the bass is more on the left and the treble is more on the right, I would maybe widen it to accentuate that effect. There's not much melody going on in the left ear, an upper register counter-point in the left channel would fit quite nicely I reckon.

I think you need to go easy on the filters though, there are a few too many for me. The effect gets stale after repeated listens and your song ends up sounding like one big filter sweep! I'd also like to hear the main groove go on for a bit longer. You have a lot of snare hits and fills breaking the flow of the song when I would like to really lock into the rhythm for a little while.

There is lots of dynamic movement in this song, it's definitely enjoyable to listen to but I'm not sure how it cope in a club.

Review Request Club.

aliaspharow responds:

Yeah i wasnt thinking club either... lol but yeah, i guess there are way to many filters...
Thanks a bunch for the review

THANK CHRIST!!!

Brilliant! You are the exception to the rule sir! I now have certifiable proof that not all FL users try to make dance music. You've made me happy!

This track is great, it kept me guessing the whole way through and made me want to listen to it again. I love the 7/8 intro going into the 4/4 with the snare on every beat, that gives it a rolling, train-like sound and carries the build to the piano crescendo. The kick coming in out of the piano crescendo is timed perfectly, I was just starting to miss it at and that very moment, in with the kick! Nice touch. The lead line at 2:14 could be a bit more expressive I feel. It's a bit of a whirlwind of notes where a few choicely chosen legatto passages, some glides and vibrato would have really helped bring the solo alive.

I reckon you can improve the sounds you've used in places also. I don't think the track is balanced particularly well across the frequency range. Some more low end would really help the track. Your bass sound isn't chunky enough and the drums are a little low-fi. That's great in the intro but it would have been really nice to hear a thick, punchy snare come in at the same time as the kick. The piano crescendo's quite cool but you can hear where the velocities stay the same for the passage between :46 and 1:04. It gets a little annoying towards the end of that phrase but then it goes into a cool bass drop, so I can deal with it.

I love the chord progression right at the end around the 2:40 mark. Very Jeffro Tull! Keep at it though, I'm looking forward to your next track.

Review Request Club.

WizMystery responds:

I'm getting similar comments with my mastering, it's something that I've yet to really learn about. As for velocity, my current project is a guitar driven one (after finding a good library of samples), and will vary a lot in that field.

Thanks for reviewing my submission!

Age 37, Male

London

Joined on 3/26/10

Level:
7
Exp Points:
440 / 550
Exp Rank:
> 100,000
Vote Power:
4.88 votes
Rank:
Scout
Global Rank:
42,995
Blams:
56
Saves:
153
B/P Bonus:
4%
Whistle:
Normal
Medals:
21